Thursday, November 19, 2026

You Can't Handle the Truth...

It was retired actor and film maker Jack Nicholson who coined the phrase, "You can't handle the truth." The writers of A Few Good Men, had Colonel Nathan R. Jessup (Mr. Nicholson), responding to a heated cross-examination in a courtroom, saying..."You have the truth," to which Jack thought it would better serve the situation, to improvise for a more impressive overture. He was correct in that assumption.

It became one of the most quoted lines in film history and frequently appears in pop-culture exaggerations, even today. I know you've heard it. Maybe not so much now as back in the day when I was a tad younger. But, it was used excessively, once upon a time.

Even though we might express ourselves in a manner of speaking as if it were a joke, it always comes off as the other party feeling attacked. Yet, one has to wonder if there might actually be some truth in the statement. Why can't we handle the truth? Why is it that when truth is spoken that is against our own observations, our own convictions, we immediately take offense? 

Why can't we handle the truth? I have a few ideas... 

  • Anger feels powerful, while shame feels weak: 
Admitting a painful truth requires one to sit with vulnerability, regret, or possibly embarrassment. Many times we become angry because of it, and instantly flip the script, turning a feeling of helplessness into a feeling of control and righteousness. Often blaming the other person. Or, at the very least accusing the other one as having done the same thing. And more than we have.
  • The fight response: 
When truth threatens someone's worldview or identity, the brain often processes it the same way it processes a physical threat. Becoming angry is the mental equivalent of swinging back to make the threat go away. It especially gets tense when family is added to the mix.
  • Blame shifting: 
Getting angry at the messenger, we change the subject from "Is this true?" to "How dare you attack me?" We get in a defensive mode and by this point there is no chance of reasoning with us. It's at this point one should just back away. Remove themselves from the conversation.


How am I doing? Sound like a situation you've dealt with occasionally?

As with many of my musings, they pop into my head unannounced. Many times just because. Other times they come by way of keenly watching, listening, and asking myself why. Why is this happening? 

I started this blog post early this morning when the thought invaded the time right before sitting with Today's Reasoning post on FB. I didn't want to forget the subject line, so I began the first paragraph and went on to complete what I had started. Anywho...It's how my brain works, folks...

As always, here you will find me...in Mary's World.

#myjourney #lifeissues #diverson #truthwillprevail 

P.S.

I would love to hear your thoughts. Having lived a very long life, I don't offend easily...if at all.




No comments:

Post a Comment